What Happened to Men? The Loss of Biblical Manhood

David M. Tyler, PhD

Something has happened to our understanding of what it means to be a man. For generations, men were generally expected to grow up, accept responsibility, work, protect and provide for their families, remain faithful to their wives, raise their children, and contribute something useful to the people around them.

Certainly, men have never done these things perfectly. Sin has always distorted manhood. Men have been selfish, abusive, irresponsible, unfaithful, passive, and proud throughout human history. But today the confusion goes deeper.

Increasingly, we seem uncertain about what a man is supposed to be. Strength is sometimes confused with aggression. Authority is confused with control. Leadership is treated with suspicion. Male and female differences are often viewed as problems to overcome rather than part of God’s created order.

At the same time, many men themselves have retreated from responsibility. Some remain boys emotionally long after they have become men physically. Others pursue pleasure while avoiding commitment. Some surrender spiritual leadership in their homes. Others measure manhood by career, physical strength, sexual conquest, possessions, hobbies, or personal independence. The result is confusion from both directions.

Our culture does not know what to expect from men, and many men no longer know what they should expect from themselves. So we need to ask a more fundamental question:

What happened to biblical manhood?

The answer begins by returning to the One who created man.

Manhood Was God’s Idea

Biblical manhood did not originate with a particular generation, culture, political movement, or social tradition. It begins in Genesis.

“Then God said, ‘Let Us make mankind in Our image, according to Our likeness…’”
— Genesis 1:26, NASB

Scripture tells us that God created both male and female in His image.

“So God created man in His own image, in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them.”
— Genesis 1:27, NASB

Men and women therefore possess equal dignity, and value before God. But equality does not mean sameness. God deliberately created humanity male and female. Sexual distinction was not an accident produced by history. It existed before sin entered the world.

Genesis 2 gives us an even closer look at God’s creation of the first man. God formed Adam, placed him in the garden, gave him work to accomplish, gave him His command, and later created Eve as his wife.

Before there was a culture telling Adam what manhood meant, there was God. That is crucial. We cannot understand what a man is by beginning with what culture says about men. We must begin with what God says about men.

Sin Distorted Manhood

Genesis 3 changed everything. When the serpent tempted Eve, Adam was there. Genesis 3:6 tells us that Eve “gave some to her husband with her, and he ate.”

Adam failed. The man who had received God’s command did not faithfully exercise his responsibility. Rather than standing firmly upon what God had said, he participated in rebellion against God. Then, when God confronted him, Adam attempted to shift responsibility:

“The woman whom You gave to be with me, she gave me some of the fruit of the tree, and I ate.”
— Genesis 3:12, NASB

Notice the pattern. Passivity. Disobedience. Then blame. We still see those patterns in men today.

Sin did not eliminate manhood, but it corrupted it. Strength can become domination. Leadership can become selfishness. Responsibility can become blame-shifting. Sexual desire can become lust. Work can become an idol. Courage can become recklessness.

But there is another distortion that receives less attention. Men can simply withdraw. They can become passive. They can allow someone else to carry responsibilities God has given them.

Biblical manhood is distorted both when a man abuses responsibility and when he abandons it.

The Problem Is Not Masculinity Itself

One of the difficulties in contemporary discussions about masculinity is that sinful expressions of masculinity can become confused with masculinity itself.

Men can certainly behave sinfully. A man can be harsh, domineering, sexually immoral, arrogant, violent, selfish, or controlling. Scripture condemns such behavior. But the biblical solution to sinful masculinity is not the elimination of masculinity. It is godly masculinity.

The answer to a domineering man is not a passive man. The answer to a harsh man is not a weak man. The answer to selfish leadership is not the abandonment of leadership. The answer is a man whose character and conduct are increasingly brought under the authority of Jesus Christ.

This is where Christians must be careful. If culture defines the problem, culture will also define the solution. Scripture gives us something better.

Jesus Shows Us That Strength and Love Are Not Enemies

If we want to understand godly manhood, ultimately we must look to Christ. Jesus was never weak. He confronted hypocrisy. He overturned tables in the temple. He endured hostility. He spoke truth when that truth was unpopular. He willingly walked toward suffering and death.

Yet no one who reads the Gospels carefully could reasonably describe Jesus as selfish, cruel, domineering, or obsessed with proving His strength. He welcomed children. He showed compassion. He wept. He served. He touched those others avoided. He patiently taught His disciples even when they repeatedly failed to understand. And ultimately, He laid down His life.

Jesus said:

“Greater love has no one than this, that a person will lay down his life for his friends.”
— John 15:13, NASB

That is completely different from the world’s picture of manhood.

The world often measures strength by how much power a man can exercise over others. Christ demonstrates strength through obedience, courage, truth, sacrifice, and love. Biblical manhood is not about proving how powerful you are. It is about using whatever strength God has given you in faithful service to Him and to others.

From My Counseling Office

Over many years of counseling individuals, marriages, and families, I have seen what happens when men abandon responsibility. Sometimes it appears dramatically. A husband leaves his family. A father becomes involved with another woman. A man refuses to work. A husband becomes abusive.

Those failures are obvious. But sometimes male passivity is much quieter. A wife carries nearly all the spiritual responsibility in the home. She is the one concerned about church. She talks with the children about spiritual matters. She worries about their behavior. She prays with them. She addresses problems. She makes the difficult decisions.

Meanwhile, her husband is physically present but spiritually disengaged. He may work hard. He may pay the bills. He may love his family. But he has gradually surrendered the spiritual responsibility that should matter most.

I have watched wives become exhausted carrying responsibilities their husbands should have helped carry. I have also watched children grow up without seeing a clear example of a man who takes spiritual truth seriously.

The problem is not always that men are openly rebellious. Sometimes the problem is simply that they are absent from the responsibilities that matter most.

Biblical Leadership Is Not Domination

The biblical teaching about male leadership has often been misunderstood. Some reject it because they associate leadership with superiority or control. Others have distorted it by using biblical language to justify selfishness. Neither represents Scripture.

Consider what Paul tells husbands:

“Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself up for her.”
— Ephesians 5:25, NASB

That verse leaves no room for selfish domination.

A husband is not told to make his wife serve his interests. He is commanded to love her as Christ loved the church. And what did Christ do? He gave Himself.

Biblical leadership therefore carries an enormous responsibility. It means taking initiative in love. It means accepting responsibility. It means serving rather than demanding to be served. It means being willing to sacrifice personal comfort for the good of others. It means leading while remaining under the authority of Christ.

A man who demands submission while refusing sacrificial love has profoundly misunderstood biblical leadership.

Men Need Responsibility

One of the great mistakes we can make with men, especially young men, is expecting too little from them. Men need responsibility.

Boys need to learn that becoming a man means more than becoming physically mature. They need to learn to work. To keep their word. To control their desires. To treat women honorably. To endure hardship. To accept correction. To protect rather than exploit. To serve rather than demand. To take responsibility when they fail.

Paul wrote:

“Be on the alert, stand firm in the faith, act like men, be strong. All that you do must be done in love.”
— 1 Corinthians 16:13–14, NASB

Notice how strength and love appear together. Biblical strength is not reckless aggression. It is strength governed by truth and love.

Our young men desperately need that message. They do not need to be taught to apologize for being men. They need to be taught how to become godly men.

The Battle Begins in the Heart

The crisis of manhood cannot ultimately be solved by telling men to “man up.” Behavior matters, but biblical change goes deeper. Jesus said:

“For from within, out of the hearts of people, come the evil thoughts…”
— Mark 7:21, NASB

A man’s passivity comes from somewhere. So does his anger. His selfishness. His lust. His fear. His desire for approval. His refusal to accept responsibility. His obsession with success. His need to control others.

These are not merely bad habits. They reveal what is happening in the heart. That is why biblical manhood must begin with a man’s relationship with God. A man cannot lead well if he refuses to be led by Christ. He cannot exercise authority rightly if he rejects God’s authority. He cannot love sacrificially while living primarily for himself. He cannot teach his children to follow God while God remains peripheral in his own life.

The battle for biblical manhood is ultimately a battle for the heart.

Men Must Recover the Courage to Stand

Scripture repeatedly calls God’s people to courage. That courage is especially necessary when obedience becomes costly.

Men need courage to remain faithful to their wives when temptation appears. Courage to say no to pornography. Courage to discipline their children when ignoring the problem would be easier. Courage to admit when they are wrong. Courage to ask forgiveness. Courage to resist the pressure to conform. Courage to speak biblical truth without becoming harsh or quarrelsome. Courage to stand when others will not.

Joshua was told:

“Be strong and courageous! Do not be terrified nor dismayed, for the LORD your God is with you wherever you go.”
— Joshua 1:9, NASB

Biblical courage is not confidence in ourselves. It grows from confidence in God. The courageous man is not the man who never feels fear. He is the man who obeys God even when obedience is difficult.

So, What Happened to Biblical Manhood?

Biblical manhood did not disappear from Scripture. God has not revised His Word. What has changed is our willingness to define manhood according to that Word.

Some have distorted manhood into domination, pride, sexual conquest, or self-centered power. Others have reacted by treating masculinity itself as the problem.

Many men have simply retreated into passivity, entertainment, career, hobbies, or personal comfort. None of these is the biblical answer. God calls men to something better. He calls men to responsibility. Faithfulness. Courage. Self-control. Sacrifice. Leadership. Service. Love. And above all, submission to Jesus Christ.

We do not need to return to some romanticized period in American history. Every generation has had sinful men and serious failures. We need to return to Scripture.

The church does not need men who are proud of their masculinity while ignoring Christ. Families do not need domineering men who demand authority. And our children do not need passive men who leave spiritual responsibility to someone else.

We need men whose strength is governed by love, whose leadership is marked by sacrifice, whose convictions are grounded in Scripture, and whose lives are submitted to Jesus Christ.

That is not outdated manhood. That is biblical manhood.

---

Featured Book: The War Against Biblical Manhood

What does Scripture actually teach about being a man in a culture increasingly confused about masculinity?

In The War Against Biblical Manhood, I examine the cultural messages reshaping our understanding of men and contrast them with God’s design for responsibility, leadership, courage, sacrifice, and faithfulness.

If you want to understand these issues more deeply and examine what Scripture teaches about biblical manhood, The War Against Biblical Manhood develops these truths in greater detail.

📖 Read the Ebook — Instant PDF Download
🎧 Listen to the Audiobook — Instant Audio Download